Review: The Yard by Alex Grecian

The Yard by Alex GrecianFormat read: paperback ARC picked up at conference
Formats available: ebook, paperback, hardcover, audiobook
Genre: Historical mystery
Series: The Murder Squad, #1
Length: 432 pages
Publisher: Putnam
Date Released: May 29, 2012
Purchasing Info: Author’s Website, Publisher’s Website, Goodreads, Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Kobo, Book Depository

1889, LONDON.

JACK THE RIPPER’S REIGN OF TERROR IN FINALLY OVER, BUT A NEW ONE IS JUST BEGINNING.

Victorian London—a violent cesspool of squalid depravity. Only twelve detectives—The Murder Squad—are expected to solve the thousands of crimes committed here each month. Formed after the Metropolitan Police’s spectacular failure in capturing Jack the Ripper, the Murder Squad suffers the brunt of public contempt. But no one can anticipate the brutal murder of one of their own…

A Scotland Yard Inspector has been found stuffed in a black steamer trunk at Euston Square Station, his eyes and mouth sewn shut. When Walter Day, the squad’s new hire, is assigned to the case, he finds a strange ally in Dr. Bernard Kingsley, the Yard’s first forensic pathologist. Their grim conclusion: this was not just a random, bizarre murder but in all probability, the first of twelve. Because the squad itself it being targeted and the devious killer shows no signs of stopping before completing his grim duty. But Inspector Day has one more surprise, something even more shocking than the crimes: the killer’s motive.

My Review

Jack the Ripper changed the world. He wasn’t the first serial killer, but he was the first one to create the kind of worldwide media frenzy that we are only too familiar with today.

The Ripper created the type of spectacle that the media loves, in an era when the newspapers (think of that, newspapers) were only just discovering the power of the press to sensationalize.

When Jack wasn’t caught, that frenzy turned on the Metropolitan Police. The late 1880s were the very dawn of forensics and investigative techniques. No one was prepared to profile a serial killer. But the press howled for a scapegoat, and the public lost confidence in the police.

Ripper Street DVD(If you’ve ever watched the TV series Ripper Street, this is the same time period. Not only does it give you a terrific picture of the setting for The Yard, but Ripper Street is just plain awesome. Dark, but awesome.)

The story of The Yard is a murder investigation. After the Ripper killings, this Scotland Yard created not merely what 21st century police would call a Homicide Division, but a Major Case Squad within that division. In other words, a “Murder Squad”.

Their first serious case is the murder of one of their own: a Detective Inspector is found stuffed into a steamer trunk in Euston Station, with his eyes and mouth sewn shut. It is going to be Detective Inspector Walter Day’s first major case since he was promoted to Inspector and moved to London from Devon.

No one is sure he is up to the job, including himself. Because the killer is after him. At least, one of them is.

Escape Rating A: The Yard is an amazingly well put together story. It’s a historic mystery, and it’s a police procedural at a time when that police procedure was being invented. Forensics compared to what we know now were pretty minimal. Reading the story of this “Murder Squad” being created as it solves its first cases is awesome.

As a police procedural, this is a “cop shop” book. Grecian brings the work of the police to life. Even though this is a different era from our own, they still feel like police. A lot of the grunt work is the same, even when technology is non-existent.

The characters were people that you wanted to follow. In this story, those are mainly the men, because women weren’t police in the 19th century, but the glimpses of their backstories have depth. One of the fascinating characters is the pathologist, Dr. Kingley, who seems to be running the entire forensic pathology department as a one-man-band on his own time and his own dime (or shilling).

But the two members of the Murder Squad itself are the people whose eyes we see through. Walter Day, who is new to London and isn’t sure if he should be there, and Constable Hammersmith, who got himself out of the coal mines and was made to be a copper.

Not only are the characters incredibly well-drawn, but the research into the period is meticulous. Grecian has brought the gaslight era back to life in The Yard.

The Black Country by Alex GrecianRight now, I’m trying to figure out why I let the ARC of The Yard sit around since last June. It was on my 2012 most anticipated list, but when I got it I didn’t get around to reading it until now. I’d be kicking myself harder but Murder Squad #2, The Black Country, just came out this month. I can jump right in!

If this sounds like your cup of tea, or if you’re interested in an alternative investigation of the Ripper case itself, try Lyndsay Faye’s Dust and Shadow.

***FTC Disclaimer: Most books reviewed on this site have been provided free of charge by the publisher, author or publicist. Some books we have purchased with our own money and will be noted as such. Any links to places to purchase books are provided as a convenience, and do not serve as an endorsement by this blog. All reviews are the true and honest opinion of the blogger reviewing the book. The method of acquiring the book does not have a bearing on the content of the review.

The Sunday Post AKA What’s On My (Mostly Virtual) Nightstand 6-2-13

Sunday Post

We finally have a sunny weekend in Seattle! YAY!

Friday at MPOW (my place of work) we opened the boxes on two of the books coming out on Tuesday, June 4. Libraries do get “hot” books a few days ahead, so that we have time to get them ready to give to the waiting public on the publisher laydown date.

Heart of Obsidian by Nalini Singh

Notice I didn’t say shelve. Usually these titles don’t see a shelf for months.

Friday we received both Sylvia Day’s Entwined with You and Nalini Singh’s Heart of Obsidian. I’m looking forward to reading both of them, but…I’ll buy my own copy of Heart of Obsidian. I’m perfectly content to wait for my name to come up on the hold list for Entwined with You. I can wait a month or more to read more Crossfire angst. I want to know about Kaleb now!

Winner Announcement:

The winner of the ebook copy of Jen Greyson’s Lightning Rider was Erin F.

For the Love of Mythology Blog HopCurrent Giveaway:

For the Love of Mythology Blog Hop:
$10 Amazon Gift Card from Reading Reality
Grand Prize for the Hop $45 Amazon GC or $45 woth of books from The Book Depository plus ebook prize package
Check out the hop participants for other fabulous prizes

 

 

 

Antiagon Fire by L.E. Modesitt, Jr.Blog Recap:

Memorial Day 2013
A Review: Imager’s Battalion by L.E. Modesitt, Jr.
B Review: Don’t Bite the Bridesmaid by Tiffany Allee
B Review: The Shirt On His Back by Barbara Hambly
B+ Review: Big Sky River by Linda Lael Miller
For the Love of Mythology Blog Hop

 

 

Big Sky Summer by Linda Lael MillerComing Up This Week:

Big Sky Summer by Linda Lael Miller (blog tour review)
Q&A with Linda Lael Miller + Giveaway of Big Sky Summer
Deadly Games by Lindsay Buroker (review)
Gaming for Keeps by Seleste deLaney (blog tour review)
Interview with Seleste deLaney + Giveaway of Gaming for Keeps
Jack Absolute by C.C. Humphreys (blog tour review)
Sneak Peak at Jack Absolute #2 + Giveaway of Jack Absolute
The Yard by Alex Grecian (review)

What are your plans this week?

Review: The Shirt on His Back by Barbara Hambly

The Shirt on His Back by Barbara HamblyFormat read: print book borrowed from the library
Formats available: ebook, hardcover, paperback
Genre: Historical mystery
Series: Benjamin January, #10
Length: 256 pages
Publisher: Severn House Publishers
Date Released: June 1, 2011
Purchasing Info: Author’s Website, Publisher’s Website, Goodreads, Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Kobo, Book Depository

Abishag Shaw is seeking vengeance for his brother’s murder – and Benjamin January is seeking money after his bank crashes. Far beyond the frontier, in the depths of the Rocky Mountains, both are to be found at the great Rendezvous of the Mountain Men: a month-long orgy of cheap booze, shooting-matches, tall tales and cut-throat trading. But at the rendezvous, the discovery of a corpse opens the door to hints of a greater plot, of madness and wholesale murder …

My Review:

There’s a banking crisis. Too many people lose everything they have invested when the banks fail, and their investments are suddenly worthless. Major banks close. Jobs are hard to come by. People who were doing mostly okay start to think they might lose their homes to foreclosure.

Sounds familiar, doesn’t it?

But in The Shirt On His Back, the tenth of Barbara Hambly’s Benjamin January historical mysteries, the banking crisis is the Panic of 1837, under the new Presidency of Martin Van Buren.

Ben January, a free man of color in New Orleans, is a Paris-trained surgeon who is not permitted to practice in the pre-Civil War U.S. In the South, he has to keep his papers with him at all times to prevent being falsely picked up as a runaway slave.

He makes his living as a piano player, and he is excellent at that profession. He also gives lessons to the mixed-race daughters of liaisons between the local planters and their mixed-race mistresses. Women just like his sisters.

His wife Rose runs a school for girls. But families cut back on lessons and school when times get tough. Then the bank closes, and their savings are lost.

Sometimes, Ben solves murders, by assisting the New Orleans Police in the person of Lieutenant Abishag Shaw. Shaw has come to trust Ben’s judgment, a far and delicate reach across race and class in that time and place that they have both come to value.

So when Shaw comes to Ben with a job offer, Ben takes it, no questions asked. He needs the money. And he trusts Shaw.

Ben should have asked some questions first, because Shaw sets out on the road to vengeance, to a place where no one will stay his hand, where no one will punish him for shooting the man who killed his brother.

1837 Rendezvous
1837 Rendezvous by Alfred Jacob Miller

But it is the journey of a lifetime. A trip into the Rocky Mountains, to see a way of life that was already dying. They are heading to a fur trappers’ rendezvous to trap a killer. Unless he traps them first.

Escape Rating B: The two things that stand out in this story are the portrait of the fur trappers’ rendezvous and that we finally get some hints about Shaw’s background.

By 1837, the world of the fur trappers was coming to an end, and some of them, at least, knew it. Beavers were being hunted to extinction. The Natives’ way of life was being undermined by “civilization”, disease and alcohol. Most of all, the pristine, uninhabited wilderness was getting crowded with colonists. Americans were moving towards the “Oregon country”.

There’s a patina of nostalgia throughout the story. Men who can see their world coming to an end, and Ben January’s yearning for the wife he left behind in New Orleans.

The story we follow is Shaw’s need to find the man who murdered his younger brother Johnny. The problem is that Shaw doesn’t know what the murderer, Frank Boden, even looks like. So we have a search, an investigation, and finally, some resolution, although not exactly the one that Shaw was hoping for.

Centennial by James MichenerThe murder investigation takes a backseat to the adventure story. Although the wilderness adventure is fascinating (and reminded me fondly of the early chapters of James Michener’s Centennial), Benjamin January’s story loses something when one of its most important characters is missing.

I missed New Orleans.

***FTC Disclaimer: Most books reviewed on this site have been provided free of charge by the publisher, author or publicist. Some books we have purchased with our own money and will be noted as such. Any links to places to purchase books are provided as a convenience, and do not serve as an endorsement by this blog. All reviews are the true and honest opinion of the blogger reviewing the book. The method of acquiring the book does not have a bearing on the content of the review.

The Sunday Post AKA What’s On My (Mostly Virtual) Nightstand 5-26-13

Sunday Post

I’m going to make this a short and sweet Sunday Post. It’s a three day weekend here in the U.S. and I hope that you’re having a terrific time if that applies to you! (It’s a typical cloudy weekend in Seattle, but any three-day weekend is a great weekend)

Current Giveaway:

Lightning Rider by Jen GreysonLightning Rider by Jen Greyson (ebook)

Blog Recap:

B+ Review: The Perfume Collector by Kathleen Tessaro
C Review: Chasing Mrs. Right by Katee Robert
B+ Review: Lightning Rider by Jen Greyson
Guest Post on the Importance of Mentors by Author Jen Greyson + Giveaway
B Review: Doctor Who: Festival of Death by Jonathan Morris
B+ Review: Dark Triumph by Robin LaFevers
Stacking the Shelves (46)

Antiagon Fire by L.E. Modesitt, Jr.Coming up this week:

Review: Antiagon Fire by L.E. Modesitt Jr.
Review: Don’t Bite the Bridesmaid by Tiffany Allee
Review: The Shirt on His Back by Barbara Hambly
Review: Big Sky River by Linda Lael Miller

What are you reading this week?

Stacking the Shelves (46)

Stacking the Shelves

For those of you in the U.S., I hope you’re having a marvelous three-day weekend!

This week’s stack was originally relatively small, and then I opened my Hugo voting packet. The list below is far (very far) from everything in the packet, it’s just my first pass at the books I know I want to read. The full packet is ginormous.

Reading Reality Stacking the Shelves May 25 2013

For Review:
The Accidental Demon Slayer (Biker Witches #1) by Angie Fox
The Angel Stone (Fairwick Chronicles #3) by Juliet Dark
A Beautiful Heist (Agency of Burglary & Theft #1) by Kim Foster
The Black Country (Murder Squad #2) by Alex Grecian
Chasing the Shadows (Nikki and Michael #3) by Keri Arthur
Don’t Bite the Bridesmaid (Sons of Kane #1) by Tiffany Allee
The Garden of Stones (Echoes of Empire #1) by Mark T. Barnes
The Plague Forge (Dire Earth #3) by Jason M. Hough
A Study in Silks (Baskerville Affair #1) by Emma Jane Holloway
With This Kiss: The Complete Collection by Eloisa James

Purchased:
Sweet Starfire (Lost Colony #1) by Jayne Ann Krentz

Hugo Voting Packet:
Captain Vorpatril’s Alliance (Vorkosigan Saga #15) by Lois McMaster Bujold
Chicks Dig Comics: A Celebration of Comic Books by the Women Who Love Them edited by Lynne M. Thomas and Sigrid Ellis
Chicks Unravel Time: Women Journey Through Every Season of Doctor Who edited by Deborah Stanish and L.M. Myles
Throne of the Crescent Moon (Crescent Moon Kingdoms #1) by Saladin Ahmed

Review: The Roots of Betrayal by James Forrester

The Roots of Betrayal by James ForresterFormat read: ebook provided by NetGalley
Formats available: ebook, hardcover, paperback
Genre: Historical mystery, Historical fiction
Series: Clarenceaux Trilogy, #2
Length: 448 pages
Publisher: Sourcebooks Landmark
Date Released: July 1, 2011
Purchasing Info: Author’s Website, Publisher’s Website, Goodreads, Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Kobo, Book Depository

Your Choice. Your Faith. Your Fate.

1564: Catholic herald William Harley, known as Clarenceux, guards a highly dangerous document. It’s a manuscript he’d rather not have—destruction and death have followed in its wake. But things get much worse when the document is stolen, and he plunges into a nightmare of suspicion, deception, and conspiracy. As England teeters on the brink of a bloody conflict, Clarenceux knows the fate of the country and countless lives hang in the balance. The roots of betrayal are deep and shocking, and the herald’s journey toward the truth entails not just the discovery of clues and signs, but also of himself.

My Review:

“The roots of betrayal lie in friendship; those of treason lie in loyalty.”

This quote could easily sum up this second volume of the trials and tribulations of William Harley, the Clarenceaux King of Arms. When you read the line, it seems so obvious, as if it should be a common saying.

Imagine my surprise to discover that the fiction author James Forrester was quoting himself (as historian Ian Mortimer) from his book The Greatest Traitor. It doesn’t make the words seem any less self-revealing, or any less “true” in the case in William Harley.

The lesson of Clarenceaux’ story could be taken as “keep your friends close and your enemies closer”, although the man seems to have a difficult time determining which are which.

And, to use our vernacular instead of his, if it wasn’t for bad luck, he wouldn’t have any at all.

History remembers the Elizabethan Age (maybe we should be calling it the First Elizabethan Age) as a Golden Age. England defeated the Spanish Armada. Shakespeare’s career flourished. Elizabeth’s reign was the time of England’s glory.

But we forget that it didn’t begin that way. Elizabeth’s reign had a shaky start. There was a significant amount of religious dispute between Catholics and Protestants. Many wanted a return to Catholicism, and fomented revolts in favor of Mary Queen of Scots, Elizabeth’s putative heir.

The problem with Elizabeth being the “Virgin Queen” was that virgin queens have no children to inherit their thrones.

sacred treasonInto the middle of this we have the roots of William Harley’s betrayal. In Sacred Treason (reviewed at Book Lovers Inc.) Harley is entrusted with a document proving that Queen Elizabeth was illegitimate because her mother, the executed Anne Boleyn, was pre-contracted to Henry Percy. (This was a big deal in the 1500’s)

At Anne’s trial, this was one of the many charges, but there was no documentary evidence.

There are conspirators who demand that Harley use the document to start a pro-Catholic rebellion. Harley, although he is Catholic himself, refuses. He is wise enough to know that rebellions only lead to death and repression.

Then the document is stolen from its hiding place in his house. Harley believes that he has been betrayed. But by whom?

Every single person who has ever known about that document operates on the belief that someone has betrayed their trust. Clarenceaux is certain that the widow Rebecca Machyn, his partner in misfortune in Sacred Treason, has betrayed him. Francis Walsingham, an agent of the crown, is certain that Harley has betrayed the government and is working for towards a Catholic conspiracy.

Harley’s wife Awdrey believes that Harley has betrayed their marriage vows.

Because Harley is certain that his life is forfeit for losing the document, he chases after Rebecca Machyn, believing she has the document. Walsingham chases after Harley.

Where is the document, and why was it stolen? Who is at the heart of what conspiracy? Where is the betrayal? How many betrayals are there?

Escape Rating B+: The Roots of Betrayal was every bit as much of an immersive experience as Sacred Treason. In some ways, it was better. Part of the emotion of Sacred Treason required following along with William Harley’s falling slightly in love with Rebecca Machyn, and that part didn’t work.

The Roots of Betrayal is a story of honor and betrayal. Political conspiracies and political paranoia. Lies and deceit. This time, Harley follows Rebecca because he thinks she’s stolen this document and he’s afraid for his life and the lives of his wife and children. He knows what happened last time. His house was ransacked, his possessions were destroyed, his family had to flee London. He was nearly killed.

He’s also correct that a rebellion will only end in repression and death, not just for the rebels themselves, but anyone who might be thought to be sympathetic. If the rebels are Catholic, then what little tolerance currently exists will be ruthlessly suppressed, probably in blood.

His chase leads him through dark places. He forgets everything but his need to find that document and prevent anyone from using it. He finds more honor, for certain strange definitions of that word, among thieves and pirates, than he does among supposedly ladies and gentlemen.

Sacred Treason fascinated because of the political plotting. The Roots of Betrayal is almost a “road novel”. In his desperation to find the document, Clarenceaux leaves behind his comfortable, middle-class life and finds himself in more and more desperate straits at ever turn.

The people he meets along his journey are what push the story, and the reader, forward. Each time he learns of another link in the chain, he meets a new group of amazing characters. Each person’s agenda layers on top of, or thwarts, his.

The idea that pirates have more honor than supposed gentlemen is one that sticks with you when you’re done.

***FTC Disclaimer: Most books reviewed on this site have been provided free of charge by the publisher, author or publicist. Some books we have purchased with our own money and will be noted as such. Any links to places to purchase books are provided as a convenience, and do not serve as an endorsement by this blog. All reviews are the true and honest opinion of the blogger reviewing the book. The method of acquiring the book does not have a bearing on the content of the review.

Stacking the Shelves (44)

Stacking the Shelves

Doctor Who Who-ology by Mark CavanThis year is the 50th anniversary of Doctor Who. Hard to believe, isn’t it? Two of the review books are part of the 50th anniversary collection from BBC Books. It was kind of a thrill to get the Royal Mail package from England this week.

It had an extra surprise inside. Doctor Who: Who-ology, The Official Miscellany by Cavan Scott & Mark Wright. It’s kind of a dictionary of Doctor Who. For a fan, it’s pure gold, but I can’t imagine reviewing it. Still, it’s a glorious prezzie and I can’t resist opening it every few minutes just for kicks.

Stacking the shelves Reading Reality May 11 2013

For Review:
Any Other Name (Split Worlds #2) by Emma Newman
The Apple Orchard (Bella Vista #1) by Susan Wiggs
Chasing Mrs. Right (Come Undone #2) by Katee Robert
The Clockwork Scarab (Stoker & Holmes #1) by Colleen Gleason
Dangerous Curves Ahead (Perfect Fit #1) by Sugar Jamison
Desire by Design by Paula Altenburg
Doctor Who: Festival of Death (Past Doctor Adventures #35) by Jonathan Morris
Doctor Who: Ten Little Aliens (Past Doctor Adventures #54) by Stephen Cole
Flirting With Disaster (Camelot #3) by Ruthie Knox
From This Moment On (Sullivans #2) by Bella Andre
Gaming for Keeps by Seleste DeLaney
Hearts in Darkness (Nikki & Michael #2) by Keri Arthur
Hellhound by Kaylie Austen
Home to Whiskey Creek (Whiskey Creek #4) by Brenda Novak
How the Light Gets In (Chief Inspector Gamache #9) by Louise Penny
The Look of Love (Sullivans #1) by Bella Andre
Love Me (Take A Chance #2) by Diane Alberts
The Miss Education of Dr. Exeter (Phaeton Black #3) by Jillian Stone
Mist by Susan Krinard
The Newcomer (Thunder Point #2) by Robyn Carr
The Sky: The Art of Final Fantasy Slipcased Edition by Yoshitaka Amano
Stranded With a Billionaire (Billionaire Boys Club #1) by Jessica Clare

Purchased:
Dead Ever After (Sookie Stackhouse #13) by Charlaine Harris
Delicate Freakn’ Flower (Freakn’ Shifters #1) by Eve Langlais

Borrowed from the Library:
Good Man Friday (Benjamin January #12) by Barbara Hambly

Stacking the Shelves (40)

Stacking the Shelves

I listened to a webinar last week sponsored by Library Journal. Several publishers were highlighting their spring and summer books. It’s always good to hear about what’s coming out, even when it’s not in a genre I read myself.

The Human Division by John ScalziOne of the publishers was Macmillan, Tor’s parent company. Even though they didn’t talk science fiction, they sent this nice email afterwords, saying that any librarian who attended could get white-listed on Edelweiss for any Macmillan title. My eyes bugged out when they listed The Human Division as one of the books I could get.

I didn’t just get John Scalzi’s The Human Division, his return to his Old Man’s War universe, I’ve already inhaled it. And written my review. The only reason I haven’t posted it yet is because it’s too early to publish.

Just what I needed…more books. Yes!

Stacking the Shelves March 30 2013

For Review: (ebooks)
Beauty and the Blacksmith (Spindle Cove #3.5) by Tessa Dare
Dancing With the Devil (Nikki & Michael #1) by Keri Arthur
Death of Yesterday (Hamish Macbeth #29) by M.C. Beaton
His Southern Temptation (Boys Are Back In Town #2) by Robin Covington
The Human Division (Old Man’s War #5) by John Scalzi
Lord of Darkness (Maiden Lane #5) by Elizabeth Hoyt
A Riveting Affair by Candace Havens, Lily Lang, Patricia Eimer
Rules of Entanglement (Fighting for Love #2) by Gina L. Maxwell
Seduction by M.J. Rose
The Taming of Ryder Cavanaugh (Cynster Sisters Duo #2) by Stephanie Laurens

Borrowed from the Library: (print)
Ran Away (Benjamin January #11) by Barbara Hambly
The Shirt On His Back (Benjamin January #10) by Barbara Hambly

Stacking the Shelves (39)

Stacking the Shelves

This week my shelf contains a “sweet 16” stack of books. Think of it as my contribution to NCAA “March Madness” even though both of my schools are out of the running this year.

Supernaturally Kissed by Stacey KennedyNow that I mention sweetness, the books that were the sweetest to get were Mystically Bound and Eternally Devoted, the final (I hope final) books in Stacey Kennedy’s Frostbite series. Stacey has this diabolical tendency to end her stories on nail-biting cliffhangers, so I’ve been waiting for Eternally Devoted to be released before I got Mystically Bound. Stacey sent review copies, so I’ll finally get to see if Tess and Kipp get their elusive happily ever after. If you have fond memories of the movie Ghost, start this series with the fantastic Supernaturally Kissed and prepare to see the trope marvelously reversed.

Reading Reality Stacking the Shelves March 23 2013

For Review: (ebooks unless noted)
The Best of Connie Willis by Connie Willis
Bristol House by Beverly Swerling (print ARC)
Claws of the Cat (Shinobi #1) by Susan Spann
Date by Mistake by Candace Havens, Gwen Hayes, Jill Monroe, Rosemary Clement-Moore, Shannon Leigh
The Engagements by J. Courtney Sullivan
Eternally Devoted (Frostbite #4) by Stacey Kennedy
The Forever Knight (Bronze Knight #4) by John Marco (print ARC)
The Magic Circle by Jenny Davidson
Mystically Bound (Frostbite #3) by Stacey Kennedy
River Road (Sentinels of New Orleans #2) by Suzanne Johnson
Royal Street (Sentinels of New Orleans #1) by Suzanne Johnson
The Stuff of Dreams (Star Trek: The Next Generation) by James Swallow

Purchased: (ebooks)
A Cinderella Christmas Carol (Suddenly Cinderella #1.5) by Hope Tarr
Operation Cinderella (Suddenly Cinderella #1) by Hope Tarr

Borrowed from the Library: (print)
Hollow Earth (Hollow Earth #1) by John Barrowman and Carole E. Barrowman
Stalking the Unicorn (John Justin Mallory #1) by Mike Resnick

Review: The Bughouse Affair by Marcia Muller and Bill Pronzini

Bughouse Affair by Marcia Muller and Bill PronziniFormat read: print book borrowed from the library
Formats available: ebook, hardcover, audiobook
Genre: Historic Mystery
Series: Carpenter and Quincannon #1
Length: 272 pages
Publisher: Forge Books
Date Released: January 8, 2013
Purchasing Info: Author’s Website, Publisher’s Website, Goodreads, Amazon, Barnes & Noble, Book Depository

In The Bughouse Affair, this first of a new series of lighthearted historical mysteries set in 1890s San Francisco, former Pinkerton operative Sabina Carpenter and her detective partner, ex-Secret Service agent John Quincannon, undertake what initially appear to be two unrelated investigations.

Sabina’s case involves the hunt for a ruthless lady “dip” who uses fiendish means to relieve her victims of their valuables at Chutes Amusement Park and other crowded places. Quincannon, meanwhile, is after a slippery housebreaker who targets the homes of wealthy residents, following a trail that leads him from the infamous Barbary Coast to an oyster pirate’s lair to a Tenderloin parlor house known as the Fiddle Dee Dee.

The two cases eventually connect in surprising fashion, but not before two murders and assorted other felonies complicate matters even further. And not before the two sleuths are hindered, assisted, and exasperated by the bughouse Sherlock Holmes.

My Review:

At the beginning, it felt like I was missing something. Like any detective, I started to hunt for that elusive clue. But I didn’t hunt hard enough until after I’d finished the book.

I do enjoy the occasional mystery, and historic mysteries in particular. Marcia Muller and Bill Pronzini are both certified masters of their craft, but I had never gotten around to sampling either of their long-running series.

The Bughouse Affair, the first volume in their joint Carpenter and Quincannon series, seemed like the perfect opportunity to rectify my lack of experience with their work.

However, about that missing clue…this may be the first book in the series, but it’s not the first book with one of its protagonists. Pronzini has written three earlier John Quincannon books. And there’s an even earlier short story collection.

Bughouse (meaning crazy) indeed.

About this particular bughouse affair, we have a mystery within a mystery. Sabina Carpenter and John Quincannon are partners in a detective agency. This wouldn’t be so unusual, but the setting is gaslamp San Francisco of the 1890s.

Sabina Carpenter is Quincannon’s co-owner and business partner, not his life-partner. And she is a trained detective. Her history is as detailed as his. Carpenter was a female Pinkerton, a Pink Rose just like the very real historic figure Kate Warne.

Carpenter and Quincannon are hired to solve two seemingly separate cases. One is the case of a house-breaker who is methodically working his way down a list of the Great Western Insurance Company’s clients.

The other is a pickpocket, or dip, who is scaring away business at an amusement park.

And in the midddle of both of their cases is an English visitor to San Francisco who claims to be Sherlock Holmes. Is the crazy man interfering, or can he really solve either, or both cases? Or is he just getting in the way?

Escape Rating B: The portrayal of turn of the century life in San Francisco was absolutely riveting. Carpenter and Quincannon make a fascinating pair. They are equals, but Quincannon does have some problems with that. Not so much because Carpenter is a woman, but because he has difficulty believing that anyone is his equal. John Quincannon does not work well with others.

He also hopes that someday he and Sabina can be more than business partners. If that day is ever going to come, it is a very long way off.

The authors did a terrific job with dialog. The partners, and the police, used the 19th century words and phrases for all the ne’er-do-wells and criminals. Pickpockets were “dips”, safecrackers were “yeggs”. It added to the tone of the book and made the characters more “real”.

However, adding Sherlock Holmes into the mix took away from the building of the partnership between Carpenter and Quincannon. This was the period after Reichenbach when Holmes was in San Francisco, but while he is on-stage, reacting to his outsized personality overwhelms everyone else.

Art of Detection by Laurie R KingLaurie R. King handled Holmes’ visit to San Francisco as a lost manuscipt within her Kate Martinelli story The Art of Detection. By keeping the manuscript separate, she almost managed not to let Holmes overwhelm her Martinelli story. But it was a near thing even for her.

I hope that Carpenter and Quincannon have future outings in gaslamp San Francisco where they do not have to contend with interfering English consulting detectives. Their partnership will develop much better if they solve cases on their own.

***FTC Disclaimer: Most books reviewed on this site have been provided free of charge by the publisher, author or publicist. Some books we have purchased with our own money and will be noted as such. Any links to places to purchase books are provided as a convenience, and do not serve as an endorsement by this blog. All reviews are the true and honest opinion of the blogger reviewing the book. The method of acquiring the book does not have a bearing on the content of the review.